John Delach

On The Outside Looking In

The Final Demise of the SS United States

In like a lion. Out like a lamb.

When the SS United States first entered service in 1952, almost 50,000 people witnessed her departure from New York City for Liverpool, England. Our country’s new super ocean liner made the fastest crossing of the Atlantic Ocean ever by a commercial liner winning the prized  Blue Riband award.

Eastbound, The United States (The Big U) made the crossing in 3 days, 10 hours and 40 minutes averaging 35.50 knots or 41 mph.

Westbound, she made the crossing in 3 days, 12 hours and 41 minutes averaging 35.51 knots or 39.5 mph.

This record has never been surpassed and the ship remained in service until 1969 when she became a victim of the jet passenger plane revolution. For 57 years the Big U remained out of service at a pier in Philadelphia. Over the years, many proposals were made from all directions with different ideas of what to do with this aging hulk all to no avail until it was decided to allow the grand old liner to be scuttled forming a grand artificial reef a destination for scuba divers.

The Big U’s luck ran out and the idea to scrap her began to rear its ugly head in 2024. Just when this idea became serious, the folks who oversaw operations in Florida’s pan handle region along  the Gulf of Mexico proposed the revolutionary idea of buying the ship, towing it from  Philadelphia to a shipyard in the Gulf where it would be cleared of all pollutants so that it could deliberately be scuttled 22 nautical miles off the coast of Destin-Fort Walton Beach in 188 feet of water to become the largest artificial reef.

On November 11, 2016, the sinking process began at 2 pm. It was carried on prime video and was estimated to take 45 minutes. Instead, several things went wrong and the scuttling took over eight hours and by the time the Big U went under, it was the dead of night without any fanfare and few witnesses.

The deal was consummated with the United States Conservancy that had gained ownership of the Big U in 2011. The president and co-founder is Susan Gibbs who is the president and co-founder. She is also the granddaughter of William Francis Gibbs, the designer, naval architect and godfather of the United States. Her purpose was to protect the Big U from being scrapped which is why she jumped on this idea of scuttling the ship.

The Big U was towed from Philadelphia in early 2025 and arrived at a shipyard in Mobile, Alabama on March 25th.

The liner’s two massive stacks were also removed and set aside for delivery to a new museum honoring the SS United States that will be built on land near-by to her new resting place.

Any trace of fuel oil, chemicals or material that could poison the environment were removed from the ship’s tanks, pipes and other areas while some of the tanks on board the ship were filled with sea water in preparation of her scuttling. Holes were strategically cut in various places in the outer hull and the inside compartments to accelerate her sinking process.

The game plan was to scuttle the Big U on Thursday, November 12th and the liner was towed out from Mobile on Monday, November 9th. She arrived on site the next day allowing then powers that be to accelerate the date to scuttle the Big U to Nov. 11th, one day earlier due to a poor weather forecast.

The SS United States was successfully scuttled via controlled flooding so that the liner came to rest upright in 180 feet of water. The top deck of the ship is only be about 55 feet below the surface so to be accessible for use by recreational divers.

It is just a shame that all of us Big U fans could not witness the scuttling, but I am pleased she is now in her final resting place.

On the Outside Looking In will not be published on Nov. 25th, but will return on Dec. 3rd.

Happy Thanksgiving

The Sands of The New York Times Are Running Out

On a recent Saturday morning, I opened our garage door at about seven and walked out onto  the driveway to pick up The Times and Newsday only to find they had yet to be delivered. In this age of fewer and fewer print subscribers, the morning papers are no longer delivered by different drivers. The Times, Newsday, the Daily News, the Post and the Wall Street Journal are all delivered by a single person in our community.

Normally, I would have returned inside, but it was a nice day so I stayed outside. My instinct was bang on, an old white car slowly came around the curve leading to my house. I could see plastic bags being thrown to the left and right as it proceeded toward me.

I stood at the curb as I watched, George, the driver approach me. With a smile on my face, I greeted him. His front seat was a sea of newspapers. As he handed me my two papers, he told me, that he was a retired delivery man and only did this when they needed him. We talked about how few customers still seek printed papers. “George, I’m 82 and I wonder will I go first, or my printed newspapers before me?”

George replied, “I figure The Times is the key. If they eliminate their printed editions, all of our other dailies will soon follow suit.”

I think George is correct, so let’s take a look at what is happening at The Grey Lady.

On this November 5th, the NYT reported that in the last quarter, they had added 420,000 additional digital subscribers bringing their total up to 13,800,000. This addition keeps the company on pace to meet its goal of achieving 15 million subscribers by the end of 2027.

Meanwhile, the number of their print subscribers dropped from 570,000 to 540,000.

The NYT first began offering digital subscriptions in 2011. At that time, the number of print subscribers varied between 1.1 million and 1.2 million readers.

At the end of 2011, digital readers reached 390,000. Here is how it continued:

2014 = 910,000

2017 = 2.5 million

2020 = 7.5 million

2022 = 9.6 million

2025 = 12.78 million

I love my printed newspapers and they remain the sources of many of the pieces that I write for my blogs. Most times these sources appear off the beaten track. My favorite of all times appeared in a Saturday edition of the NYT in a column titled: “On Religion.”

It was the story about the North Dakota Police who obtained a surplus security dog from Isreal. Unfortunately, they could not communicate with the dog as he only understood Hebrew. The handler had to utilize one of the two Rabbis in the state to learn how to communicate with his new mate.

Today, I believe that the sand beneath the NYT is running out. The regular monthly cost for a digital subscription to the paper is between $25 and $30 a month while the cost for a written subscription is slightly less than $200 a month.

Of course, the pride at the Gray Lady to continue the written edition is a serious factor, but as the number of subscribers continues to slip-slide away, how long can this go on?

Tick, tick, tick…

Avoid the First and Last Train Car

Most people who know me are aware that when I was six-years old in 1950, my mother made me take an oath that I would never ride in the first car or the last car of a commuter train. This oath followed a disastrous crash between two trains that killed 74 riders on the Long Island Railroad (LIRR) on the Wednesday evening before Thanksgiving. All of the fatalities were in the last car of the first train and the first car of the second train.

On October 28th, a similar crash took place on a high-speed line in Spain between Madrid and Barcelona. One train was stopped while the second was cleared to proceed. Neither engineer or driver as they are now called was at fault. The computer system had failed and a dispatcher in the central control in Madrid authorized the second train to move again without restricting its speed. He should have restricted the speed to 40 kilometers or 25 mph, but he didn’t. The other train remained stopped awaiting its orders to move. The second train reached a speed of over 100 MPH when it struck the first train 15 miles later killing 69 riders.

In 1977, we moved to Port Washington and I began my daily commute on the LIRR. Not only did I keep my vow to my mother, I grew more sophisticated about where I should sit on the train. Since Port Washington is the end of the line, every day I selected to ride in the fifth car from the back of the train. This put me in the middle.

Going home, I usually rode in the third or fourth car from the head of the train out of Penn Station.

You ask why I selected these cars? Let’s take a look at the recent wreck. The first train consisted of eight coaches. The photos in the  NY Times shows that the rear car, coach No. 8, was knocked off the track and cut into two large pieces. Coach No. 7 was knocked completely off the track and sent down the embankment. Coach No. 6 was knocked partially off of the tracks with the five remaining coaches left intact on the rails.

The first coach of the second train was also heavily damaged. The second coach was seriously derailed. The third coach was partially derailed and the remaining three coaches of this six-car train remained on the rails. Let the record show that the middle of a train is the safest place to sit.

Have I ever made an exception? Yes, but only when I was under duress not to miss a train scheduled to leave. Other than that, the answer is no.

Once I ran into an old acquaintance when boarding the train in Port Washington. He asked me to join him as he was about to enter the last coach. “No thanks,” I said, “No first or last for me and have a good day.” 

No Game Today

Last Friday, our cable company sent us a technician to update and improve our television and internet service. Since then I have not had any internet service until today. I have no faith that this service will last.

I cannot send you a piece for fear that it will go astray so, God willing, I will be back in business by next Wednesday.

I am thankful that I had this opportunity to explain what’s going on so please stay tuned and hopefully, “On the Inside Looking Out” can resume next week.

Golden Retrievers Love of Water

Part One: The Big Orange Dog

Harry was the first of the big orange dogs who became our family dog and showed us why Golden Retrievers are special. He set the standard for all to come. Bright and alert, his favorite pastime was swimming in the still waters of Stone Pond in Marlow, New Hampshire. Stricken with arthritis early on, his passion continued even when walking became difficult. We rigged a wooden ramp covered with carpet fabric to assist him getting into and out of the back of our truck. We chauffeured him to local ponds and his nose sensed water before he could see it. Excited and agitated, he had little patience until he knew we had arrived at his favorite destination.

Disregarding his infirmity, he rushed from the truck as soon as we opened the rear gate and jumped into the pond. Strong again, he started swimming and what a swimmer he was, fast and smooth with deliberate strokes that created a graceful wake that spread across the water as he progressed in his pursuit of the tennis ball I had launched from the shore. To accommodate his range and speed, I hit the ball as hard as I could with an old Prince tennis racquet. Upon reaching the ball and capturing it in his mouth, he would return in his triumphal and graceful manner. As soon as he reached shore, he released the ball, turned and plunged back into pond swimming in the direction that he anticipated I would hit the ball next. Watching for the telltale splash, he picked up his pace and swam in that direction. If he didn’t see a splash in a timely manner, he lifted his chest out of the water and began swimming in larger and larger circles until he spotted the floating ball.

Time and again, he continued to retrieve balls without noticeable fatigue or loss of interest. His endurance never ended. It was me who finally gave up on the idea that I could outlast him. Once, out of the water, his pain and stiffness returned and he let me help him back into the truck. When necessary, I lifted him in my arms so that he didn’t have to negotiate the ramp. I didn’t mind getting drenched in the process.

Part Two: Morning Swim

Instinctively, she senses the water. Perched on the back seat of our SUV, Maggie extends her nose out through the partially opened window, her senses and  experience tell her that this is the way to the beach. Like a child, after a long automobile ride to a favorite seaside destination, she cannot contain herself as the Gulf of Mexico reveals itself.

Mary Ann lets us off before continuing on to her journey to her morning tennis lesson. Maggie and I will make our morning trek along the beach and back to our Sanibel rental. Maggie is a maniac, an ill-behaved Golden Retriever who luckily found her way to the two of us who can deal with her insanity.

Once on the ground, I place my hand under her collar. Tugging, bucking, crying, she pulls me along until I secure my footing into the sand. I speak to her as I look up and down the beach. “It’s okay, Maggie, it’s okay.” The beach is clear; only a few early morning shellers, no unattended children and no other dogs. I take her collar in one hand and draw her close making her leash go slack. With my other hand, I open the clasp and let go.

Maggie crouches and pushes off with all her strength, kicking up sand as she bolts toward the water quickly closing the distance until she reaches the surf and plunges in. She swims through small breakers, turns, catches the next wave and body surfs back to shore.

I jog toward the sun and Maggie darts ahead, establishing her own routine. She explores the beach, searching for sticks and coconuts to carry, sea gulls and osprey to scatter, or a decaying fish to sniff and, if its scent is acceptable, to roll upon.

“Maggie, stop that.” I yell, but she ignores me until I have moved too far ahead for her to be comfortable. She stops and trots to catch up, overtakes me and veers back into the water, tail held high, to ride the surf again.

And so, our morning routine unfolds until we reach the public beach  populated with a few early arriving families ending my insane Golden Retriever’s daily morning activity to run freely and frolic in the surf.

She understands. I attach her to the leash as we begin our land journey back to the rental. I am proud that she loves swimming so much. When she came to us, she didn’t know how to swim. We taught her using tennis balls having her fetch them at the water’s edge. We threw them further and further until she had to accept floating and began to understand how to swim and reach them. Maggie quickly caught on to what being an aquatic retriever was all about and she even learned how to body surf.    

As we walk back to the house, she’d looks at me and whines. I look back at her and say: “It’s okay girl, tomorrow is only a day away.”

Crossing Greenland’s Prince Christian Sound

Fog, not dense, but persistent, reduces visibility forcing James Russell-Dunford, the captain of the Maasdam, to warn us that he might be forced to abort the planned west-to-east transit of Prince Christian Sound. “We will be approaching an entrance to the sound in a half-hour. Helicopter observations report the sound to be ice-free, but we’ll have to see if the fog persists when we reach the entrance before I can commit to a passage.”

As he maneuvers the cruise ship, the fog dissipates revealing the mouth of the fjord and the brown-gray rock that is Greenland. Still Captain Dunford remains cautious, “I may have to turn around if conditions deteriorate, but right now I am satisfied with visibility and ice conditions.”

His caution is warranted. The Maasdam carries almost 1,300 passengers and a crew of over 500. Even though visibility is greatly improved, the day promises to be wet and cold enough to force me to prepare carefully before I venture out on deck to observe and photograph this passage. No shorts this July 23, 2010; the air is close to winter here in the North Atlantic.

I don jeans and a golf shirt, rain pants, a nylon wind breaker, wool vest and a water-proof rain jacket. I cover my head with a Tilley rain hat; grab a towel to protect my digital camera when not in use and off I go to the open stern of the ship. I pick the stern to document this passage avoiding the wind, spray and misery of the open bow.

What a passage! The low-lying rocks that frame the entrance quickly rise up to form  rugged and barren cliffs with peaks close to 5,000 feet producing canyons that tower over the ship. How different it would have been had sun been out, but the low clouds and mist add drama that trumps color. The passageway twists and turns as the captain navigates the ship through channels that narrow to less than 300 feet. Layers of clouds wrap around the cliff faces, clinging to the sides obscuring their flanks, but allowing crags and peaks to poke through. Other times, the drab gray, brown and green formations rise triumphantly free of the mist.

I am able to roam the deck freely taking photos from various vantage points as not many of my fellow “cruisers” delight in taking on the cold, rain and wind. Those that do don’t stay long and our ranks are thinned to a foolish and hearty few after the first hour.

Waterfalls drain pockets of ice and snow, so many that soon I take them for granted. The channel follows a crazy quilt pattern with twists and turns revealing new drama. Glaciers descend down mountains, some directly into the sound. They calve icebergs that dot the sound. Fortunately, the bergs are widely spaced and do not pose a danger. The captain’s enthusiasm grows as we continue and, at some point he silently decides we will complete the journey including a side-trip to the lone Inuit village in the sound.

Approximately 150 men, women and children inhabit Aappilattoq, an isolated hamlet of  small metal-sided houses perched precariously on flat rocks and earth at a junction of canyons. Painted bright blue, red, and yellow, they clash with the dull, dreary land; appear transient, as if by tomorrow they will be gone without a trace.

The inhabitants fish for sustenance and hunt seal to make a living. The captain sails the Maasdam past the village into a wide basin to make a 180 degree turn to continue the west – east passage. The ship’s horn bellows as we complete the turn calling out boats from the village, white open skiffs propelled by huge outboards. Four appear, a single man in the first, two in the second, six in the third including three children and three adults in the last. Two of the drivers stand steering by means of long handles attached to the motors. They wave and take photographs of us as we take photos of them.

Before lunch, my wife surprises me with a welcome cup of hot, thick Dutch pea soup the crew is serving on several decks. It is so good that I have more with lunch; a welcome respite from the wind and rain. But I don’t tarry and I leave my wife and mates to resume my vigil. Not one of them thinks to join me and I can’t blame them.

The rain is relentless, ultimately forcing me to seek shelter where I wait and watch for the next bend in the channel, the next waterfall, iceberg, mountain top or glacier. Covering the top of my camera with a succession of dry towels, I dash out to photograph each scene before making my retreat.  When we leave the sound just after 4 pm, I have taken over 250 photos. Tired and wet I am pleased with the experience, especially since my expensive Nikon digital camera survived the elements.

What an experience. A glass of Jameson Irish Whiskey is my delight as I remove my soaked gear, take a shower and prepare for dinner.

Bonus Post for October 7, 2026

Goal Line Stand

John Delach

October 2026

Last Sunday, October 4th, I attended the Giants home game against the Arizona Cardinals with my son, Michael and his two sons, Drew and Matt.

I am going to keep this piece simple and ignore the ride to and from Long Island to New Jersey, the comradery, the good food, drink, the conversations at our tailgate, the weather, and our trek into and out of the stadium.

I am going to ignore the back and forth scoring that occurred during 95% of the contest and concentrate on the last 5% of this game.

Please note that I can’t identify almost all of the names of the players who participated in the action. Also, my timing is close, but less than accurate.

As this scene opens, the Giants have just committed a pass interference penalty giving the Cardinals a first down, eight yards from the Giants goal line at our end of the field giving the four of us a bird’s eye view of Big Blue’s goal line stand.

The Giants are winning by six points meaning the Cardinals must score a touchdown to tie the game and a single extra point to win the game. They only have eight seconds left on the clock with no time outs left.

The Cardinals decide not to call for a running play because, if the runner fails to score, time will run out before they can run another play.

The entire crowd is standing. And completely engaged hoping our team prevails:

First down: The Cardinal QB throws a ball toward his receiver in the end zone that the Giants defender breaks up for an incompletion and no flags.

Second down: See the First down above.

Third down: See the First and Second down above.

Fourth down: Four seconds left, cornerback Banks picks off the pass and returns it 102 yards for a touchdown as time runs out…and no flags!

Mike, Matt, Drew and I were crushing each other, jumping, stomping and shoving in ecstasy. Our buddy Jeff jumped on our pile joining us in our celebration of one of our Giants biggest goal line stands of all times.

What a hell of a win, and a win is a win, is a win!

Go Giants.   

Presidential Helicopters

President Trump made another basic change to the White House grounds, as usual,

without seeking Congressional approval. Curiously, this time, the media and all of us who react angrily to these decisions seemed to ignore it.

He approved the construction of a 100-foot in diameter helipad surface consisting of four-inch-thick durable granite slabs sourced from a California quarry designed to resist the intense heat and exhaust from the newer, heavier Marine One helicopters. It is located on the south lawn of the White House that was regraded so that the pad is completely flat and level with the horizon.

The Presidential Seal covers the entire diameter of the pad with an eagle-shaped centerpiece. Trump autographed the back of that piece before it was put into place.

Beyond helicopter landings and takeoffs, the sturdy pad is to double as a platform for outdoor events, gatherings and cocktail receptions. 

The defense contractor, Lockheed Martin paid for the project. (Sikorsky, the Connecticut based helicopter manufacturer, now a subsidiary of Lockheed Martin, built the new presidential copters.)

After a great deal of debate, Congress, the Defense Department and the Marine Corp agreed to introduce the Sikorsky VH-92A Patriot Helicopter as the new chopper for the presidential fleet. The Patriot replaces the Sikorsky VH-30 Sea King that had been in use for four decades. No matter your political beliefs, I believe, “It’s about time.”

Why a concrete helipad? After all, helicopters have been using the White House South Lawn as a landing and takeoff pad since President Dwight David Eisenhower began using copters in 1957.

The reason is the exhaust from this more powerful chopper is more intense and could set the grass on fire. The federal organizations responsible for the president’s safety and the Marine Corp agreed that a concrete pad was necessary before they could sign-off on the VH-92A being named Helicopter Number One.

Trump noted: Dwight Eisenhower didn’t need a Helipad at the White House for those little choppers, but America needs one now.”

The history of Helicopter Number One began with Ike who loved Camp David. After all, he re-named the presidential retreat that FDR had called Shang Ri La after his brother, his grandson and his own middle name.

While Ike loved Camp David, he hated the amount of traffic he had to endure to make the trip by car from the White House. On July 12, 1957, Ike made his first flight on a helicopter from the White House to the camp using a Bell Ranger (H-13J). This was a bubble topped helicopter, the civilian version of the copter made famous during the Korean War. (Think of the helicopters who delivered the wounded to the field hospital in the TV series MASH.)

The Secret Service loved it because of its reliability. It could carry the pilot and two passengers, but only one in comfort. Also, it didn’t have air conditioning and it flew at a speed of

100 MPH with a range of 150 miles. The Secret Service insisted that James Rowley, chief of the White House detail, join the president in the bubble by squeezing into a third seat.

“When the president arrived at Camp David, he was sweating from an uncomfortable ride. After spending the night at Camp David, Ike drove with his family members to their home in Gettysburg, but then flew back to Washington in the Ranger. That was his second and last flight on that uncomfortable bird.”

His next helicopter ride was on Sept. 6, 1957 on a Marine HUS-1 also built by Sikorsky. Ike was pleased with this larger military transport helicopter and ordered his staff to switch to this model. The HUS-1 remained in presidential service for Jack Kennedy and Lydon Johnson before being replaced by the first version of the Sikorsky SH-30A, the Sea King.

Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford were the first presidents to use the Sea King. The A-model was succeeded by several newer versions of the Sea King that served Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, George Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, Joe Biden and Donald Trump, 45 and Trump 47.

The VH-92A should be this new bird! I envision that this copter will remain in service well into the future and the current model and its successors will serve at least a half-dozen of future presidents throughout the Twenty-First Century.

The new helipad was dedicated and went operational on Monday, September 21st.

What should have been a simple ceremony turned into another three-ring circus as

the Donald lost his national television coverage because he had banned certain networks from the White House. This brought about a TV boycott by the White House press pool.

Peter Baker of The New York Times explained what happened at his dedication of the new helipad: “He (the President) was left literally shouting into the wind as he cut the ribbon on his new helipad recorded only by (Newsmax) that could not capture his voice over the roar of Marine One.”

Oh well, it seems that Trump’s action to ban certain TV reporters from the White House has come back to haunt him, and so it goes.    

And It Rained and It Rained and It Rained

December 2018. Edited and reprinted September 2026

I wrote this to describe the worst Giants home game weather-wise that I ever sat through on December 16, 2018. The Giants lost that game to the Tennessee Titans by a score of 17 to 0.

On September 27, 2026, the Giants once again played the Tennessee Titans in a premature Nor-easter that first struck on Friday night, September 25th. I didn’t plan to attend this game as I gave my tickets away to my oldest granddaughter and her boyfriend who is a loyal Giants fan, but had never seen Big Blue in person before. It rained all game long, but this time the Giants defeated the Titans 12 to 7 in a “hold your breath” victory.

I dedicate this re-write to all of my family and buddies who attended this game. Go Giants

And it Rained and it rained and it rained

Weather impacted every home game this season.

Game outcome, not withstanding, rain prevailed.

Shorter days, colder days, rain became miserable.

We endured, but no day at the beach for sure.

And it rained.

December 2nd versus Da Bears. All day drizzle.

Mild enough, not cold, no wind, rain gear held up.

Stayed the course, all four quarters plus unwanted OT.

Joy prevailed, Giants won, hot chocolate surely helped.

And it rained

December 16, 2018. Prediction: All day-steady rain-non-stop.

Prepared: Socks wrapped in plastic, freshly polished work boots.

Waterproof down coat over sweatshirt, rain pants over jeans.

Rain hats, gloves and ponchos over everything.

And it rained.

Ready or not here we go. Joe swings by at 8 AM.

We joke: “Off to see a losing team in bitter rain.”

We few, the worthy. Summer soldiers long gone.

Yet other faithful re-appear, gather, tailgate, endure.

And it rained.

Game time, head in. The contest yet to begin.

Already losing, our rain defenses are failing.

 Water-proof turns out to be a relative term

 leaving us exposed to harm’s way.

And it rained.

Soldiers fighting a battle of endurance. Titans versus Giants.

Rain versus protection. Cold and wet versus dry.

Tyrannical forces prolong contest created to break us.

Game officials, TV and even the singer stretches by the rocket’s red glare.

And it rained.

Misery. By the Second Quarter my arms shiver.

“This is insane’” I stand: “Mike, I won’t return

until the second half.” None of us returned to our seats.

Drew and Jeff join Mike and me sheltered at halftime.

And it rained.

My alarm blasts alert: LEAVE NOW!

Drew, Jeff, and Mike SIGN ON next.

Joe and Justin need one more score.

Titans accommodate with a TD on a turnover.

And it rained

One last potty stop and a ten-minute trek to the cars.

A last, but hurried goodbye for the season, then shelter.

Shed as many sodden clothes as I can

Waze works with a tolerable post-game ride home.

And it rained

Once home, everything is damp or soaked.

No doubt, every woman in our lives intones:

“I told you so.” Of course, they are right.

We long-time fans rolled the weather dice that came up craps

And it rained, and it rained, and it rained.     

The World Trade Center and its Club

Part Two: The Club at the WTC

Revised September 2026 and originally published : October 2001

When the WTC opened, the building boom was over and the towers joined the waiting list of buildings needing tenants. The North Tower, Number 2, the first one completed, did fill up and lived up to its name as a world trade center housing steamship companies, freight forwarders and international commerce brokers of all types and description. The South Tower looked like a bust, but New York State came to the rescue housing state office workers on most floors.

I had ceased being a surveyor, but I remained in the Marine Insurance business as an insurance broker placing insurance for ocean going ships of every size and description.  Business brought me regularly to the North Tower. Located on the upper most floor was Austin Tobin’s crown jewel, The Club at the World Trade Center, his personal gift to power. A magnificent drinking and dining facility with private rooms, cigars, a staff that exuded the snobbery of a private club, three martini lunches and a men’s room so magnificent, it could be an appropriate setting for a national leader to lay in state. The Club kept its own accounts and neither cash nor credit cards were accepted.

When the press became aware of the privacy and opulence of The Club, all hell broke loose. How could a public agency promote a subsidized private club? Tobin had to pacify the press and politicos and so, at night it became “Windows on the World” the unique public restaurant 110 floors in the air. The NY Times first review read in part: “…as to the quality of the food, you cannot beat the view.”

At lunchtime, The Club remained members only. A mentor, Charlie Robbins, introduced me to The Club. Charlie drank Bombay Gin Martinis and loved to entertain there. He especially liked to show it off to visiting British brokers and their wives. This was an era when British firms sent their senior and most promising junior brokers to the United States for two or three weeks at a time. The Labour Governments tax rate was 90% and these trips provided an alternate method of compensation. And so, they came to New York in May and October when the weather is best. 

Charlie’s greatest coup came during a dinner in one of their private dining rooms. He disappeared and, on his return announced: “ May I have your attention. I have arranged a special event for the ladies, a tour of the most magnificent men’s room in the world.” Charlie had convinced the staff to temporarily close the men’s room, and he proceeded to escort the ladies, including my wife, on a private tour to the delight of all.

Charlie encouraged me to become a member. We worked in midtown and the cost was discounted if you were north of Canal Street. During my 20 years as a member, I hosted many a lunch and dinner there. I utilized their private rooms to set agendas, deal with crises, congratulate success, say goodbye to retirees, good luck to transferees and accomplish other matters of commerce.

The view was paramount and at times dramatic. On crystal clear winter nights, the lights of the city and surrounding areas stretched like jewels. Manhattan buildings stood out, as did the brightest pockets of light, the airports. Rivers, bays and oceans glowed if the moon was full while we looked down upon helicopters as they flew by. Jets flying into and out of the three airports traced the sky against the backdrop of the stars. During one dinner, low clouds swept in and we could no longer see the street or other buildings, but we could still see the stars. Such was life in the fast lane 1970s and 1980s style.

However, as the 1990s arrived, The Club became an anachronism. The era of the private luncheon clubs was over. The Harbor View Club, Drug and Chemical Club, The Wall Street Club and the infamous Whitehall Club, with its deadly bartender, Spiro, had all closed. Business had changed in focus, diversity and geography with a reduced tolerance for lunchtime drinking. This and loss of tax deductibility, the cost of space and the desirability of their locations conspired to hasten their demise.

The terrorist bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993 had forced The Club to close, I thought permanently. So, it was with surprise that I opened an announcement in 1995 advising The Club would re-open in 1996. I re-joined at a discounted fee, but seldom used it as I too had changed. I hosted my last dinner in the fall of 1999 for a group of French underwriters from AXA Insurance Company. The summer before, they entertained us and our client at their chateau in Bordeaux, a once in a lifetime event. My colleagues and I decided to take them to The Club and the weather cooperated fully. The view was superb, the food good and the wine far too expensive, but they were as impressed as the French will ever admit. 

I resigned from The Club in 2000 when I retired and never went back. On September 11th the Club died when the North Tower fell taking with it 72 of its staff and 91visitors who were trapped inside. It was no longer relevant, but with its collapse, how it collapsed, the world changed for me, for us, forever.

To relieve my post-destruction gloom, I searched for and found my old photographs taken as a young man illustrating the promise of their construction together with my last membership card. I thought this evidence and my memories would be the epitaph. Curiously, they were not. A letter arrived with the return address being Mr. Jules Roinnel in Baldwin, Long Island. Jules was the Club’s Manager. Dated October 12th, it began: ”Dear Member:” This was a surprise, not because I am no longer a member, as I knew I remained on their mailing list, but rather that a letter was sent. The letter spoke of the 72 staff members who died and advised that two surviving luncheon clubs would offer guest privileges until the end of the year. Even though it read in part: “…the future of The World Trade Center Club is unclear.” it had an upbeat tone about it.

It turned out Jules was simply going through the motions. The Club never  gained a third life. The Club, like its era and the towers belongs to history.

May all who died there Rest in Peace.